Risks of settlement talks.

12 December 2024

Sign this or be sacked!

A settlement agreement is a legally binding agreement between the employer and employee that can resolve potential workplace disputes.

 

There are often circumstances where, in the face of a potential dispute, parties can mutually agree settlement terms which will result in an employee waiving their employment rights, in consideration for a financial payment. Until the agreement is signed, all discussions and offers, can remain off the record and parties cannot be held accountable for any provisional offers or concessions that have been made. These discussions are often referred to as without prejudice.

There are however, risks of without prejudice discussions being unprotected, if the purpose of these discussions, are abused or used as a veil to pressure an employee to accept terms. In these circumstances, the without prejudice protection is removed leaving an employer exposed to allegations of unfair dismissal.   

 

An employer's conduct during settlement discussions could be deemed improper if it is used as tactic to pressure an employee into accepting the terms offered. If the employee is warned they would be sacked if they did not agree to the employer's offer, the employee could argue that any dismissal was therefore pre-determined, exposing an employer to an unfair dismissal claim.

4 June 2024
Employment experts foresee an increase in employment tribunal cases brought by employees as a result of employers requiring employees back into the office, full time. Those who try to avoid days in the office may be faced with their employers using entry-gate data to track staff attendance. The Telegraph reports that a number of companies are now advocating a full five-day return to the office, with others enforcing a minimum number of days in the workplace. Administrative staff at Boots, who previously worked in the office three days a week, will be required to return to the office five days per week from September. Earlier this year, an Employment Tribunal rejected the case of a senior manager who claimed against her employer, the Financial Conduct Authority, because she wanted to work at home full-time. Judge R Richter ruled that the FCA was within its rights to reject the employee's request stating that there are “weaknesses with remote working.....which will no doubt be the subject of continued litigation.” Is working from home so bad? According to KPMG’s 2023, CEO Outlook Survey ( Current trends in remote working (kpmg.com) , attracting and retaining talent is a top operational priority for CEOs to achieving their 3-year growth objectives and believe that remote working can play an important role in supporting talent retention and accessing new talent markets. There will no doubt be an increased number of claims brought against employers as remote working dissipates and employer's start to change the working dynamics.
27 February 2024
Menopause symptoms can have a significant impact on women at work. Research by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development found that two thirds of working women between the ages of 40 and 60 with experience of menopausal symptoms said they have had a mostly negative impact on them at work. Of those who were negatively affected at work: 79% said they were less able to concentrate. 68% said they experienced more stress. nearly half (49%) said they felt less patient with clients and colleagues, and 46% felt less physically able to carry out work tasks. Baroness Kishwer Falkner, chair of the EHRC, said: “As Britain’s equality watchdog, we are concerned both by how many women report being forced out of a role due to their menopause-related symptoms and how many don’t feel safe enough to request the workplace adjustments."
11 February 2024
The Government has announced the rates of the National Living Wage (NLW) and National Minimum Wage (NMW) which will come into force from April 2024. The rates which will apply from 1 April 2024 are as follows: NMW Rate Increase: National Living Wage (21 and over) £11.44 18-20 Year Old £8.60 16-17 Year Old £6.40 Apprentice Rate £6.40 Accommodation Offset £9.99 
11 February 2024
New mandatory duty on employers to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace – get prepared.
by PH763790 8 January 2024
The EAT has held that an employee’s redundancy dismissal was unfair where the employer failed to carry out meaningful workforce consultation at a formative stage. The respondent company carried out a scoring exercise using a standard set of subjective criteria. The claimant scored lowest in out of three in his pool. The respondent then met with the claimant three times before dismissing for redundancy. No consultation took place with the workforce prior to the scoring exercise. The EAT held that there was a clear absence of consultation at the formative stage, which meant there was no opportunity to discuss different approaches to any aspect of the employer’s redundancy process. The decision underlines the importance of appropriate workforce consultation, even where collective consultation obligations are not triggered. De Bank Haycocks v ADP RPO UK Ltd [2023] EAT 129
8 January 2024
What are Part-Year and Irregular workers and how is their holiday entitlement calculated?
by WH Legal 30 December 2022
Strike Action - what's going on? Trade unions are representing NHS staff are in a dispute with the government over the 2022/23 pay award. NHS England has stated that the service is facing record demand on urgent and emergency care services with the months of October and November being the busiest on record for A&E attendances and the most serious ambulance callouts. As a consequence, and for the first time in history, nurses and ambulance staff have gone on strike, represented by Trade Unions, regarding a dispute over wages. Royal College of Nurses (RCN) is calling for a 19% pay rise. The government says this is unaffordable.
by WHL 8 December 2022
Flexible working from day one of employment The Government has proposed to allow employees to request flexible working from the first day of their employment.
by WH Legal 20 November 2022
World Cup and Employment Law
by WH Legal 30 March 2018
A guide to alternative pay to statutory maternity pay
Show More
Share by: